This year marks the 50th anniversary of Jaws, the blockbuster film that had beachgoers everywhere thinking twice before stepping into the ocean. While most people remember the giant shark, the suspense, and the famous two-note theme music, I’ve always thought the real story wasn’t about the shark at all.

It was about leadership.

When a young woman is attacked and killed near Amity Island, Police Chief Martin Brody wants to close the beaches until they can determine what happened. It seems like a reasonable precaution. But local officials worry about the economic impact. Summer tourism drives the town’s economy, and they fear that closing the beaches will hurt businesses and create panic.

So they delay.

They debate.

They downplay the risk.

And they hope the problem will simply go away.

It doesn’t.

The shark gets all the attention in the movie, but the leadership lesson is what happened before the shark became impossible to ignore.

The Problem Isn’t Always the Problem

One of the biggest mistakes leaders make is treating symptoms instead of addressing root causes.

In Jaws, the shark was the crisis. But the real problems were beneath the surface long before the attacks escalated.Communication broke down. Warnings were ignored. People allowed competing priorities to cloud their judgment. No one wanted to deliver the unpopular message.

Organizations do this too.

High turnover isn’t usually the problem. It’s often a symptom of something deeper. Low morale isn’t the problem. It’s a signal. Customer complaints aren’t the problem. They’re feedback pointing to an issue that needs attention.

The best leaders learn to look beyond what is immediately visible. They ask why something is happening rather than simply reacting to what happened.

Delaying Difficult Decisions Has a Cost

The mayor wasn’t a villain. He was trying to protect his community’s economy. His intentions weren’t bad. His decision-making was.

Leaders often face situations where they know action is needed, but the action is uncomfortable. Maybe it’s addressing a toxic employee. Maybe it’s confronting a culture issue. Maybe it’s having a difficult conversation that everyone else is avoiding.

The temptation is to wait. To gather more information. To hope things improve on their own. To avoid rocking the boat. But delayed decisions rarely eliminate problems. More often, they give problems time to grow.

The longer an issue remains unaddressed, the larger the impact becomes. As leaders, we have to remember that avoiding a difficult decision is still a decision.

Expertise Matters

One of the most interesting dynamics in Jaws is the relationship between Chief Brody, marine biologist Matt Hooper, and fisherman Quint.

Each brings a different perspective.

Brody understands people and public safety. Hooper brings scientific expertise. Quint contributes years of practical experience. None of them could solve the problem alone.

Strong leaders understand that they don’t need to have all the answers. Their role is to bring together the right people, listen to different viewpoints, and create an environment where expertise can be shared and respected. Too often, organizations struggle because leaders surround themselves with people who think exactly like they do.

The best solutions usually emerge when different perspectives work together toward a common goal.

What’s Beneath the Surface?

Most leadership challenges don’t arrive with dramatic music playing in the background. They show up quietly.

• A frustrated employee.
• A disengaged team member.
• A customer who stops calling.
• A process that isn’t working.
• A concern that keeps getting pushed to next month’s agenda.

The biggest threats to an organization are often the ones that everyone knows exist but no one wants to address.

That’s the lesson I take from Jaws.

The shark wasn’t the biggest danger. Pretending it wasn’t there was.

As leaders, our responsibility isn’t just to respond to the problems everyone can see. It’s to identify the issues beneath the surface before they become crises.

Because by the time the shark reaches the beach, it’s already been in the water for a while.

Want more practical leadership insights like this delivered straight to your inbox?
Grab a cup of coffee and join me for Culture, Coffee & Common Sense. Delivered bi-weekly. Always thoughtful. Never overwhelming.
👉 https://chelliephillips.com/culture-coffee-commonsense/

If you want more secrets to a thriving workplace, you can:

See why The Hollywood Magazine put Culture Secrets is on it’s must read list in 2025.

Listen to the Culture Secrets Podcast on your favorite platform.

Grab your copy of the book Culture Secrets.

Booking now for speaking and training events.

Check out my audio books: Get Noticed, Get Hired or When In Doubt, Delete It!